In a radical departure from previous book club meetings, this selection will be seat-work, and will complete the day: students will take the novel as they’ve read so far and compose a brief essay.  This will be a standard five-paragraph essay, and is due on Monday, 10/31.

book review

Go here, because it's 1995!

http://www.yahoo.com

Life of Pi:  In light of the fact that this novel is about imagination, why does Martel begin with the Author's note, which gives the impression that Pi's account is truth, not fiction?  Consider the role of theology and the idea of a spiritual journey in forming your response.

The Monster of Florence: The very title of this novel, and the moniker of the killer (Il Mostro), calls to mind the idea of a supernatural menace.  Consider ways in which the narration supports that the perpetrator of these crimes is not "human".  Look carefully to the description of the murders as well as the newspaper reporting on the crimes.

The Count of Monte Cristo:  Is Edmond a force for personal revenge, or divine retribution?  As you form your answer, consider the role of religion in Edmond’s formation and escape, the role of his priestly benefactor, and the motivations of the villains in the story.   A note: avoid moralizing whether or not you believe Edmond is right or wrong.  Instead, look at how the novel views the villains (they’re seen as “good people” but have a dark undercurrent of crime!) as well as how Edmond is in the beginning of the novel vs. his re-appearance as the myserious count.

All Quiet on the Western Front:  Are the technological and military innovations seen as a force for good, or evil, according to the novel?  Look carefully at Paul’s life at home before the war, his experiences on the lines, and how it changes him.   Also consider the idea of technology as a force which “corrupts”, such that we saw in Frankenstein.